I like to puzzle over their distant world. 'Distant mirrors'. The music that came from it can fascinate. I try to identify its particular character. It's a hybrid of italian baroque and spanish/iberian, which was itself a hybrid of native and gypsy and african and moorish influences. The gypsy part is important, because music is a gypsy *profession*. Scholars speak of 'folk' influences on Scarlatti in Spain, which is misleading: an essential difference between elite art and folk art is the intensity of training and practice. (The great difference between the gypsy musical elite and the 'white' one is that between 'oral' transmission and transmission that involves an evolving textual basis) I hypothesize that what made spanish music so interesting was the existence of a caste of professional musicians processing exciting musical influences coming to a society already culturally diverse, through Atlantic exploration (especially Africa) . Scarlatti is 'white' elite culture recognising and processing this at-that-time particularly dynamic elite 'black' culture
(a black musical elite is nomadic - you have to hit the road to make a living from music - you become white by getting a salary and being able to sit down and get Literate about your art. Scarlatti's father Alessandro may have started out black in Sicily and become white studying in Naples)
Want some story ?
Mary Barbara's parents King Joao V and Queen Maria Anna had been childless for the first three years of their marriage. So Joao had sworn to God that he would reciprocate the gift of a child with the gift of a monastery, and the minute MB was safe in her basinet he had begun to build the hugest and most beautiful monastery palace conceivable. It wasnt finished til she was 14, though often between 30 and 40 thousand people were working on it. Really! - Joao was extravagantly rich with newly-struck brazilian gold, and he was lavish with it. Genius and Opulence are lovers, according to the tenets of (the economic system of) aristocracy - like Nature and the Sun. Bewitchingly lovely was the world prepared for Mary Barabara, and she loved the music especially, and nothing musical so much as the harpsichord, for the playing of which she had a gift. So Joao dispatched instructions to his ambassador in Italy - the homeland of needy Genius then - to find the best music teacher for her. Domenico Scarlatti - son of one the most inspired composers of the age, Alessandro Scarlatti , and organist at St Peter's in Rome - was approached in his organ loft. Domenico must have thought this his lucky break: though a fantastically skillful musician, at 34 or 5 he'd given no evidence of any Genius like his father's. But perhaps this was a certain introversion - innate, or in the shadow of Alessandro's Greatness - which inhibited him, and may have attracted him to the idea of leaving the artistic hothouse of italy and retiring into well-compensated obscurity. For this he did, and he lived out his life as Mary Barbara's esteemed servant, first in Portugal, and then, when MB married Prince Ferdinand of Spain (also a melomane) in Spain.
Want some reflections on pre-romantic music making?
Scarlatti's obscurity lasted until quite recently. In the 1963 Britannica, his entry is a footnote to Alessandro's, and there's no mention of a Genius flowering late, at 'the court of the melomanes'. It's embodied in a corpus of harpsichord pieces we call 'sonatas' today. I dont know when that usage started, but I think it gives a wrong idea about the pieces - the word puts then in a category with pieces by Beethoven which are essentially different, in their *romanticism* - a romantic artwork is the 'personal vision' of an individualized Genius - romanticism privatized Genius, for the sake of marketing branded products - 'Beethoven' is a brand, and the owner of the brand, eg a Beethoven, lives (hopefully) off his cut from the enterprise. Romanticism is part of a new democratic economy. The aristocratic economy is different in conception and in practice, and its works have a correspondingly different character. Genius brings divine Creativity into presence, the arts are its media, and artists are conjurers that Opulence cultivates, and regards as 'esteemed servants' . We'll leave aside the differences between the socio-economic fields of democratic marketplace and aristocratic court (it's a fuel-supply / energy-level thing at bottom) , and focus on scarlatti's practice as salaried servant. Music-making is *playing* - it's spontaneous activity - it's not reading. But music making became reading in the romantic age - you buy a sonata and you 'play' *it*, by reading. (The profits of music in the 19th c came from the printing - the pianos were mass produced with such narrow margins they were overall being subsidized by the income from the sheet music (trust me - i could get a footnote at the libaray within hours).
Scarlatti called his pieces not sonatas but 'Essercisi', 'exercises', in the only group of them that were printed in his lifetime - about 30 - and they werent printed for sale: they would have circulated as gifts among connaisseurs: 'Professors and Dilletantes...a game of art to give you security and freedom on the harpsichord'. That's how Scarlatti described them in his only surviving paragraph. I dont think Scarlatti was Mary Barbara's private 'composer'. Before the age of sheet music, music was improvised play with instruments. Scarlatti would have produced exercises, as Mary Barbara's coach, assisting her in her own play - physically and creatively - with technical challenges and examples of modulation patterns/developmental tactics - how one crafts *a piece*. Ongoing pedagogy, for a brilliant amateur. Scarlatti as musical servant had a pedagogical role. Scarlatti's pieces got passed down through a line of musical pedagogues (catering to amateurs and musicians). Clementi and Czerny were the important teachers transmitting (a small part of) his oeuvre - Chopin got Scarlatti from teachers, and loved it, and used it in his teaching work. I dont know how many pieces he had - he would have had the 30 and maybe a few more at least. I do not yet know when it first became clear that there were in total 555 of these pieces, compiled by the aging Scarlatti at the behest of another imported servant at the melomane court, a singer and beloved confidant of Mary Barbara, the great castrato and natural noble-man Farinelli - innocently fictionalized in this successful french movie. The real Farinelli was an elegant and intelligent gentle giant probably quite free of 'hangups', but the anachronism of his movie representation as deeply embittered because of his wounding 'in the groin' was a good thing - people could identify with that, and there was a brief revival of a somewhat despised repetoire, with a gorgeous alaskan contralto named Vivica Genaux singing the hits: the concert i went to was one of the best ever, cos there were no music-snobs there, just excitable tenderhearted fags and faghags and loving performers. I went to the record shop after to get the cd, and the fag recognised me from the concert and - sweet guy - gave it to me for free.
ps Unfortunately for my theory (though probably a mere detail):
Dear Julian,
Unfortunately for that theory, the primary sources (Venice and Parma) consistently call each individual work "sonata". The only time "essercizio" is used is as an overall title for the thirty published works, and even then each of the works is headed "sonata" too...